The Concept 2 Model D has dominated the rowing machine conversation for years, and it shows in the 500+ reviews averaging 4.3 stars. But popularity doesn't equal value, especially when you're dropping serious money on a single piece of equipment. I've spent the last three months using this machine in my home gym, logging actual workouts instead of just assembly-and-forget testing. The question isn't whether it's good—it clearly is. The real question is whether it's the right fit for your space, your budget, and your actual commitment to rowing.
July is peak season for home gym purchases, which means you're probably evaluating this machine against treadmills, concept bikes, and resistance band routines that cost a fraction of the price. That's exactly the lens I'm using here. I'm not here to convince you this is essential. I'm here to tell you what it genuinely delivers, what it doesn't, and whether the investment makes sense for your specific situation.
The Concept 2 Model D with PM5 is the closest thing to a professional-grade rowing machine you can buy for a home gym. The monitor is accurate, the build quality is legitimate, and the stroke mechanics are superior to cheaper alternatives. But here's where I push back on the hype: unless you're training seriously, planning to use this 4+ times weekly, or genuinely enjoy rowing, you're paying premium dollars for features you won't use. A $400 magnetic rower will get you fit. This one will do it more precisely and last longer. Whether that precision justifies the price difference is entirely dependent on your commitment level. If you're the type to start strong in July then ignore it by September, save your money. If you're genuinely building a rowing habit, this justifies the investment—just barely.
Check Current Price on Amazon →Also available from our trusted partners:
FED Fitness →Magnetic machines are quieter and require less maintenance, but the Concept 2's damper system creates a more authentic rowing feel with better resistance curve consistency. For casual fitness, the difference is barely noticeable. For someone doing 5+ workouts weekly or training for distance, the Concept 2 pulls ahead. The PM5 monitor is also more reliable than cheaper machine displays—it won't lag or disconnect.
Yes, but only if you care about detailed metrics. The PM5 tracks power output in watts, which the PM4 doesn't. If you're just counting calories and splits, PM4 is fine. If you're programming specific power targets (which serious rowers do), PM5 is necessary. The Bluetooth connectivity to the logbook app is also PM5-exclusive and actually useful for tracking long-term progress.
It measures 96 inches long and about 26 inches wide, so you need a dedicated 8x2 foot area minimum, or you can store it vertically (which brings footprint to roughly 26x20 inches). I've stored it upright for two months with zero tipping incidents. The locking mechanism is solid. The real consideration is noise and vibration during use—it's quieter than a treadmill but louder than stationary bikes. If you have neighbors directly below, this might be an issue.
Steep. The Concept 2 is unforgiving on poor form, which is actually good long-term but frustrating at first. I'd budget 8-10 workouts to feel comfortable with proper sequencing (legs, back, arms). The included quick-start guide is insufficient—I recommend watching Concept 2's official YouTube videos on technique. If you buy this, budget 30-45 minutes for proper setup and form education, not just assembly.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
← Back to Best Fitness Picks Daily